Orff: Carmina Burana (CD review)

Sally Matthews, soprano; Lawrence Brownlee, tenor; Christian Gerhaher,
baritone; Simon Rattle, Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra and Berlin Radio Chorus.
EMI 7243-5-57888-2.

Since moving to the conductorship of the Berlin
Philharmonic some years ago, Sir Simon Rattle has been advocating live
recording with a vengeance. I admit this often produces more lively and
spontaneous results, having a real audience during the performance, but it
doesn’t always do a lot for a recording’s sonics. Such is the case with Rattle’s release of Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana, that perennial favorite
of music lovers the world over, as well as movie directors and television
producers.

First, the performance. The soloists, chorus, and
orchestra seem at first glance letter perfect, as we might expect from these
people, and Rattle’s interpretation is vigorous, to say the least. The reading
is, however, perhaps a touch too slick for its own good, lacking some of the
earthiness the work might have found by its being slowed down a tad rather than
taken at such extreme tempo changes. Rattle’s slowly and softly articulating
one section of the music and then blasting it out fast and loud in the next can
be exhilarating for a while but ultimately taxing on the mind and the ears. Nor
do his singers always provide him the best support.

Created in 1937 and based on thirteenth-century
manuscripts in Latin, French, and German, the Carmina Burana songs divide into three parts covering the pleasures
of springtime, drinking, and love, all within the framework of “Fortuna,” luck
or fate. Under Rattle, everything seems quite energetically pursued, but, as I
say, those drastic changes of pace tend to undermine the whole enterprise.

The live sound, made in the Philharmonie, Berlin, in 2004
does not appear to me as convincing as most studio recordings, the way it’s
miked making some instruments fade into the background or suddenly jump to the
forefront. The solo voices come off best, very clear and natural in their
presentation, but the orchestra fares more poorly. The sound, quite dynamic, is
rather bright in the climaxes and fortissimos, somewhat muted at other times,
and slightly thin overall. Frankly, despite the newer digital origins of the
Rattle disc, I found it inferior to the older, analogue recordings of Andre
Previn (EMI) and Eugen Jochum (DG), whose interpretations seem to me more
refined, more robust, more consistent, and, yes, better recorded.

JJP

Silfra (CD review)

Hilary Hahn, violin;
Volker Bertelmann (Hauschka), prepared piano. DG B0016798-02.

I know what you’re asking: What the heck does “Silfra”
mean?  And what exactly is a “prepared
piano”? First things first. According to Wikipedia,
Silfra refers to an area “located in the Þingvallavatn Lake in the Þingvellir
National Park in Iceland.” It’s “a rift that is part of the divergent tectonic
boundary between the North American and Eurasian plates. By virtue of its
location in the Þingvallavatn, Silfra contains clear, cold water that attracts
scuba divers drawn to its high visibility and geological importance; divers are
literally swimming between continents. The rift claims a shallow depth nearest
to the bank, but deepens and widens further out.” The disc’s booklet note says
that the place “is preternaturally still, colored in shades of blue and green
not found anywhere else. To snorkel there in a snowstorm is to be suspended in
an ancient space, feeling tiny and surrounded in all directions by an unending
otherworldly landscape.”

Violinist Hilary Hahn and pianist/composer Volker
Bertelmann (who sometimes goes by the alias Hauschka when performing on the
prepared piano) took their inspiration from the “otherworldliness” of the
Silfra region to compose and improvise the twelve selections on the disc. So,
what we’ve got here is an experimental album of music recorded the first time
the performers played it. The participants tell us “there were no retakes.
These are the moments that brought these ideas to life.”  While it may not be high art, it is mostly
appealing. 

Oh, and what is a prepared piano? According to my Random House Unabridged Dictionary, it’s
“a grand piano that has been altered for some modern compositions by having
various objects attached to its strings to change the sound and pitch, and
performance on which typically involves playing the keys, plucking the strings,
slapping the body of the instrument, and slamming the keyboard lid.” Sounds
kind of wild, no? In this case, not quite. The twelve pieces of music Ms. Hahn
and Mr. Bertelmann perform sound sometimes hauntingly beautiful, sometimes
frustratingly common, yet continuously fascinating.

The first piece on the program they call “Stillness.” One
can understand why. It feels as though it’s simply floating out there in the
aether. Unfortunately, it’s very brief, under two minutes, and could have gone
on longer.

The second piece is just the opposite of the first.
“Bounce Bounce” sounds like an Ozark bluegrass hoedown. The artists tell us
they intended the music to represent unrest, a rubber ball bouncing back and
forth. I found it rather noisy.

“Clock Winder” was by far more to my taste, a series of
sounds like the innards of a clock in motion. It has a strangely disquieting
yet vibrantly humorous quality that is quite fetching.

And so it goes. Other tracks include “Adash,” with its
weird, occasionally eerie stretches of rhythms and vibrations. “Godot” is, as
the name implies, all about waiting, with Bertelmann’s prepared piano playing
any number of parts in a quiet conversation with Ms. Hahn’s violin. At a little
over twelve minutes, it’s the longest work on the disc.

“Krakow” is the most conventional piece on the program, a
lovely melody the performers made in advance of the other music. It is the
least gimmicky and sweetest music of the bunch in its lightly melancholy way.

I think you get the idea. Most of the music is serenely
forgettable, to be sure, yet its misty, atmospheric, impressionistic visions
and its varying harmonies and sensations beg one to listen again. Despite its
not being great, classic, or enduring music, it might just be something you
find yourself returning to a few times more than you initially anticipated. Of course,
it helps to have two world-class artists to bring it all off. Otherwise, it
would merely be a couple of people appearing to make it up as they go along.

Recorded and mixed at Greenhouse Studio, Iceland, in 2011,
the sound is fine for what it is, with Bertelmann’s piano contraption spread
widely across the soundstage and Ms. Hahn’s violin a bit more precisely
located. Depending on the tune, the sounds of the instruments can be slightly
vague or almost startlingly lifelike. But I don’t suppose the performers
intended any of their music to be particularly realistic in any traditional
sense, so the oddity of the sonics probably contributes to its overall
eccentric, experimental feel.

JJP

KLIPSCHTAPE (CD review)

First-generation
stereophonic copy of the original stereophonic master. HDTT KLIPSCH-1.

First, let me allow the folks at HDTT (High Definition
Tape Transfers) to explain their new release, KLIPSCHTAPE, better than I could: “In the 1950’s, Paul W. Klipsch,
inventor of the famous ‘Klipschorn’ corner bass horn loudspeaker, began
recording live performances in stereo as ‘reference’ recordings to aid his own
loudspeaker research and development. The 1950’s saw enormous activity and
expansion in the Hi-Fi world which was spearheaded by the emergence of stereo
recordings for public consumption, and during the latter half of the decade,
the first stereophonic reel-to-reel tapes became available, produced by
recording companies such as RCA, Mercury, Westminster, and others. The tapes
proved to be so popular that in 1956 Paul Klipsch would jump on the
reel-to-reel bandwagon by founding the Klipsch Tapes Division. Headed by the
redoubtable Mr. Klipsch and assisted by future recording engineer John Eargle,
KLIPSCHTAPE produced a total of seven titles, and marked one of the first
attempts by an equipment manufacturer to make direct tape masters available to
audio enthusiasts. Klipsch’s tapes were among the earliest stereo recordings
ever offered to the public, and survive today as a prime example of primitive
but exemplary ‘purist’ recording art. Unfortunately, Klipsch’s tape enterprise
lasted only about 2 years, and is today a virtually unknown and forgotten
fragment of audio history. However, thanks to the kindness of the present-day
Klipsch company, which has made the original master tapes available to us, we
have been able to carefully transfer and preserve some of Klipsch’s amazing
recordings to CD.”

What HDTT have done is take selections from three of
Klipsch’s tapes and transfer them to CD. The disc contains twelve musical
tracks and ends with an interview with Klipsch. The music comprises small jazz
ensemble pieces and large organ works, so the results show off most aspects of
a speaker’s range and power. Whether you actually enjoy the music is probably
secondary to the recording quality involved, but in any case it is fairly well
performed and fun overall.

Now, here’s the thing: Most people today are unaware that
the state of stereo recordings hasn't really improved much (or at all) since
the early Fifties. I listen daily to brand-new recordings that haven't nearly
the depth, breadth, range, or fidelity of the Klipsch tapes, which were among
the first of their kind. Strange world.

The disc begins with the Flem Ferguson Trio (what a
wonderful name) playing the “Tin Roof Blues.” 
It’s pleasant enough and gets the program off to an arresting start.
Following that is Weldon Flanagan (another great name) playing the Wurlitzer
pipe organ in “The Yellow Rose of Texas.” Remember, these are live recordings
made in acoustically amenable surroundings; play this one loudly and you’ll
experience a truly gigantic effect. Then we hear organist John Eargle (who
would later become one of the world’s most prestigious recording engineers)
playing an Aeolian-Skinner organ in the “Carillon Sortie,” followed by the Joe
Holland Quartet doing “I Think You’re Wonderful.”

Next is an impressive organ recital by John Eargle that
includes Bach’s Toccata in D minor,
Langlais’s Arabesque for the Flute, Gigue, Liszt’s Harmonies du Soir, and Alain’s
Litanies.

From the final demonstration tape, we get three numbers by
Flem Ferguson and his Dixieland Jazz Band: “Lady Be Good,” “Way Down Yonder in
New Orleans,” and, the best of the lot, “Muskrat Ramble.” If you can’t find any
demo material in here, you just are trying. The tapes carry with them a few
background noises associated with live, unedited performance. You live with it.

The disc concludes with a June, 1954, television interview
with Paul Klipsch, about ten minutes of audio. He’s an amusing gentleman, and
the information he provides, while rather elemental, is nevertheless
captivating.

In terms of recorded sound, Paul Klipsch was a purist in
the literal sense. He made his tapes using Stephens C2-0D4 condenser-type
microphones with transformers bypassed; Berlant series 30 recording machines;
and IRISH Brand Shamrock 300 tape, some of the best products available at the
time. In Klipsch’s own words, “Unlike most tape copies, where a good deal of
‘engineering’ and ‘dial twiddling’ have been employed in the duplication
processes, KLIPSCHTAPES are recorded and duplicated without anyone ‘riding the
gain or tone controls.’ Throughout a given piece the volume level is thereby
the same as in the original performance. There are no tone controls; the flat
response maintained results from the use of precision equipment throughout.”

To be sure, the sound of the HDTT disc is quite good, if
not quite in the absolute audiophile category we know today. However, to be
fair, there are only a handful of topflight audiophile discs in that category,
so maybe the point is moot. This HDTT disc displays an excellent separation of
instruments in the jazz pieces, with the kind of wide left-to-right stereo
spread we would expect from early loudspeaker demonstration tapes. Transient
response is relatively quick; the dynamic range is reasonably expansive; impact
is strong; lows are taut; and midrange definition is fine, if to my ears a
trifle soft. Most important, I found no noticeable distortion even at very high
playback levels. Maybe in some of the jazz numbers there could have been a tad
more air to the acoustic (they’re a trifle close and dry), yet in the organ
pieces one hears a good sense of ambience and occasion, with lifelike hall
resonances.

In all, the disc provides not only splendid sound and
rewarding musical experiences but a valuable historical document that should
interest most hi-fi fans. Although there is not a lot of content involved
(about forty-four minutes of music, plus an additional ten minutes of
interview), it’s a matter of quality over quantity.

As always, the folks at HDTT make the music available in a
variety of formats for a variety of pocketbooks, from Redbook CD’s, 24/96
DVD’s, and HQCD’s to 24/96, 24/192, and 16/44 Flac downloads for playback on
high-end computer audio systems. For details, visit
http://www.highdeftapetransfers.com/storefront.php.

JJP

Saint-Saens: Complete Symphonies (CD review)

Jean Martinon,
Orchestre National de l’ORTF. Brilliant Classics 94360 (2-disc set).

Do I see a trend here? Well, it’s a trend that’s been
developing for the past decade or more: Smaller record companies are licensing
older recorded material from bigger companies and re-releasing them.  Think of PentaTone, Newton Classics, FIM,
HDTT, and now Brilliant Classics. The case in question here is Jean Martinon’s
recordings of the complete Saint-Saens symphonies, which Martinon recorded for
EMI in the early-to-mid Seventies. The thing is, it’s not as though the EMI
editions are hard to find. A quick glance at Amazon shows there are actually
four different EMI editions available new, two from the parent company, one
from EMI France, and one from EMI Japan. Yet in 2012, EMI apparently licensed
the recordings to Brilliant Classics, and they all sound pretty much the same.
Whatever, you can never have enough editions of these fine Martinon
performances, so the more, the merrier.

French composer and pianist Camille Saint-Saens
(1835-1921) wrote five symphonies; however, only one of them, the Third “Organ” Symphony, became at all
popular. Even so, its popularity is so immense, it doesn’t matter that the
others have found relatively little favor. They’re still interesting, but quite
overshadowed by their big brother. It’s good to have them all together in one
package if for no other reason than curiosity’s sake. Who knows; a person
familiar only with the Third might
soon find a new favorite among the others.

Anyway, Saint-Saens wrote his first two symphonies, the Symphony in A major (c. 1850) and the Symphony No. 1 in E flat (1853), while
he was still in his teens. Then, he wrote the Symphony in F “Urbs Roma” in 1856 for a writing competition, which
may explain why they aren’t quite as mature and well developed as the later
works. Even the Symphony No. 2 in A minor
(1859) is a relatively early, youthful piece, especially when you consider that
the composer didn’t write his monumental Third
Symphony until 1886. Thus, what we have are four symphonies written when
Saint-Saens was in his teens and twenties, and the final one over a quarter of
a century later when he was in his early fifties.

Disc one of this two-disc set begins with the little Symphony in A, unpublished in the
composer’s lifetime and seldom recorded. That’s OK; I doubt that anyone could
do it more justice than Martinon. There’s plenty of youthful vitality in the
work, and Martinon seems to delight unapologetically in it. There’s a lot of Mozart
and Mendelssohn in the music, too, which Martinon enjoys as well.

Next come the first two numbered symphonies that
Saint-Saens published. Symphony No. 1
begins with a delightfully lilting Adagio
that shows the influence of Schumann. The second movement is reminiscent of
Bizet; the slow movement of Berlioz; and the finale typical of much French
ceremonial music. Martinon pulls all of it off with finesse, making it appear
more original and substantial than it probably really is.

Then, disc one concludes with the Symphony No. 2, the best of which comes early, in the
first-movement Allegro. It displays a
lively seriousness not found in Saint-Saens’s early works. The symphony soon
transitions into a more-temperate and completely charming Adagio. The Scherzo and
finale return to the energy of the first movement, where Martinon maintains the
music’s Mendelssohnian mood and style.

Disc two opens with the unpublished Symphony in F, subtitled “Urbs Roma” (Rome city or city of Rome).
Martinon manages to infuse it with a grand sweep that is really quite engaging,
especially in the vibrant if slightly dark Scherzo.
Still, the work is really just a prelude to the composer’s monumental “Organ” Symphony that follows.

With Martinon’s handling of the Symphony No. 3 in C minor, we get an elegant, graceful, refined
reading. Not that it doesn’t catch fire, but if you want something more dashing
and exciting, I recommend Charles Munch and the Boston Symphony Orchestra (RCA
or JVC) or Louis Fremaux and the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra (EMI),
who are more explosive in the work. Nevertheless, Martinon pumps up the
adrenaline levels, too, while providing a relaxed, expansive, wholly
sympathetic interpretation.

The recordings, which EMI made in 1972 and 1974 for the
four early symphonies at the Salle Wagram, Paris, and in 1975 for the Third Symphony at the Eglise Saint-Louis
de Invalides, Paris, sound uniformly good, if a tad on the warm, soft side. The
stereo spread is wide, although the stage depth seems somewhat limited, except
in the Third, where it opens up a
little more. While the bass could be deeper for the organ, it’s a minor
concern. Dynamics also seem a bit restricted; again, not to worry. Overall,
this is an extraordinarily smooth, accommodating sound.

JJP

Grooving Classics: A String & Percussion Fest! (XRCD review)

Harold Farberman, Colorado String Quartet; Ethos Percussion Group. FIM XR24
044.

This is an odd but
fascinating one. Sonically, the disc sounds better than almost anything you’ll
find on CD, no surprise considering it is a fairly recent XRCD24 recording from
First Impression Music, FIM, whose audiophile work has been consistently good.
Yet musically, you may have to get adjusted to some of the arrangements and
interpretations.

Except for the
unfortunate title, Grooving Classics,
which conjures up in my mind visions of John Travolta and bell-bottom trousers,
we have conductor Harold Farberman’s sometimes scintillating, sometimes
eccentric reworkings of famous classical music for string quartet and
four-person percussion ensemble. Some of it works; some of it, well, not so
much. Call it an adventure.

Things get off to a good start with the second movement Andante from Haydn’s “Surprise” Symphony. The “twinkle,
twinkle little star” variation works well with a toy piano and various light
percussion, joined in the “surprise” by the strings and a big timpani drum. But
that’s followed by Farberman’s curious reworking of Mozart’s Eine Kleine Nachtmusik, which he so
distorts as to be almost unlistenable. To each his own, I suppose. The “Can
Can” from Offenbach’s Le Contes d’Hoffmann
comes off well, probably because it’s rather raucous music to begin with; the
popping of champagne corks (balloons, actually) adds to the fun. Then, the Adagio from Dvorak’s “New World” Symphony suffers from a
peculiar combination of instruments, as do some of Tchaikovsky’s dances from
the Nutcracker.

However, there are also some outstanding items on the
album, among my three favorites being Strauss’s Fledermaus overture; the traditional “Red River Valley”; and with
the Northwest Sinfonietta a special track of Faberman/Bizet’s “Habenera
Fantasia” from Carmen. You can also
find the latter two pieces on FIM Super
Sounds! (XR24 066) and FIM Super
Sounds! III (XR24 073). Anyway, as I say, it’s hit and miss.

Beyond questions of musical taste, however, there is
nothing amiss with the sound. The production team can’t be beat: Producer
Winston Ma, recording engineer Keith Johnson, and editing engineers Tam
Henderson and Paul Stubblebine. Keith and Tam you may recognize as the guiding
forces behind Reference Recordings. Recorded at the Richard B. Fisher Center
for the Performing Arts at Bard College, New York, in 2005 and using 1/2” analog
tape at 15 ips, their work results in a startlingly real sonic picture, with as
extended highs and as well-controlled lows as you’ll hear anywhere. The stage
dimensions are wide, the dynamics are strong, the ambient bloom is warm and
natural, and the overall effect is as clean as it gets. Pick the few pieces you
like best, and you have a first-rate, modern (albeit expensive) XRCD demo disc.

JJP

Debussy: La Mer (CD review)

Also, Prelude a
l’apres-midi d’un faune; Images. Daniele Gatti, Orchestre National de France. Sony
Classical 88697974002.

I have never been as big a fan of Italian conductor Daniele
Gatti as most of the world, but I have to admit there is a lot to like in his
new recording of Debussy orchestral works. Where his sometimes flamboyant style
can be annoying to me on occasion, he pretty much lights up the Debussy music,
especially La Mer and Images, which sound effervescent and
imaginative and, well, new again.

The program begins with La Mer, which French composer Claude Debussy (1962-1918) wrote in
1905 as a symbolic representation of the sea. The composer purposely meant for
the first movement, “From dawn to noon on the sea,” to be less colorful and
scintillating than the other movements, yet Gatti infuses it with a lovely life
of its own. After a warmly atmospheric introduction, it opens up beautifully
about halfway through to a rapturous melody. In the second movement, “Play of
the waves,” Gatti is appropriately playful and light, the dancing waters
luminescent, sparkling, and magical.

Then comes that well-known third-movement finale,
“Dialogue between wind and waves,” which Gatti pulls off in splendid fashion.
It’s such familiar music, it’s hard to believe anyone could do anything
particularly innovative with it without upsetting Debussy’s perfectly tuned
impressions. Nevertheless, Gatti does just that, managing to conjure up a sweetly
rugged vision of the sea that maybe even the composer didn’t imagine. In the
end, Gatti’s enthusiasm enriches the experience, making his performance of La Mer one of the more powerful and
creative you’ll find. The interpretation bears comparison to those of Martinon,
Karajan, Previn, and Stokowski, and that’s compliment, indeed.

Accompanying La Mer,
we find a rendering of Prelude a
l’apres-midi d’un faune that isn’t quite as ethereal, dreamlike, or
sensuous as those of Karajan or Martinon, but it is a solidly vivid
characterization and should not disappoint Debussy fans.

After that, we get the Images
for Orchestra, based on work Debussy wrote for piano. The composer intended
the Images to be less impressionistic
than La Mer, more precise in style
and meaning, which Gatti understands. He fills his performance with energy, to
be sure, yet it is well-directed energy without an ounce of flab to the
reading. There is no romanticizing here, nothing soft or vague. Whether it
fully captures the Spanish idiom it reflects is a matter of taste, I suppose,
but I found it full of flavor, if in its structured, glowingly ardent
presentation.

The sound, recorded in the Salle Lieberman, Opera
Bastille, Paris, and Alfortville, France, in 2011, is almost ideal for these
works. In the La Mer and Preludes it’s delicate and open, with a
wide, deep stereo separation; good tonal balance; a clean, natural lower
midrange; and a moderately resonant acoustic. There is a slight forwardness to
the upper mids, but it’s mild. While bass could be a bit stronger, dynamics are
fine. The Images benefit from even
greater impact and more sharply focused definition than La Mer, which is as it should be. Both venues suit the varying
temperaments of the music.

JJP

Byron Janis: The Chopin Collection (CD review)

Byron Janis, piano.
EMI Classics 50999 6 02898 2 7.

Although American pianist Byron Janis has recorded for
several companies--including RCA, Mercury, and EMI--it is for his work with
Mercury in the Fifties and Sixties that I personally know of his work. I have
long been a fan of his Rachmaninov, Prokofiev, and Schumann recordings, but I
seem to have lost track of him after his lifelong bout with arthritis flared up
in the Seventies and he went into semiretirement. But in the mid Nineties he
recorded these Chopin pieces for EMI, and he apparently has been working
continuously ever since. This is all the remarkable considering that he
celebrated his eighty-fifth birthday the year of this writing.

Anyway, what we have here is a collection of Chopin
mazurkas, nocturnes, waltzes, and impromptus that Janis recorded in 1996 and
1999. EMI released most of them in the 1996 album Byron Janis Plays Chopin, now out of print; and in this 2012
rerelease the company adds several more pieces that Janis recorded a few years
later after the pianist accidentally discovered two unknown versions of Chopin
waltzes. Altogether, the eighteen selections on the disc provide a superb representation
both of Chopin’s brilliance and Janis’s artistry.

My own favorite pianists in Chopin have long been Maurizio
Pollini and Arthur Rubinstein, but after hearing Mr. Janis, a pupil of Vladimir
Horowitz, I can easily see how one might change one’s allegiance. Janis’s
smooth, easy, gentle, flowing style here belies his reputation for fierce drive
and nervous tension. In Chopin, at least, the man remains relaxed yet
completely in control.

The program opens with the Mazurka No. 1 in G minor, Op. 24, which Janis plays at a moderate
pace; no helter-skelter showmanship for its own sake here. He follows it with
the Nocturne in E flat major No. 2,
Op. 55, maintaining the same low-key manner as in the mazurka, allowing the
music to float softly to our ears.

“Above all,” says Janis in a booklet note, “the essence of
Chopin’s music was zal, the Polish
word for ‘bittersweet.’ It expresses all of the tenderness and humility of
regret borne with resignation. ... It was his way of depicting the tormented
history of his beloved Poland.” And so it goes, on through the rest of the
selections, each a delicately polished gem. My own favorite tracks, for what
it’s worth? The Nocturne in B major No. 2,
Op. 32; the Waltz in A minor No. 2,
Op. 34; the Mazurka in B flat minor No. 4,
Op. 24; the Nocturne in F sharp No. 2,
Op. 15; the Nocturne in D flat major No. 2,
Op. 27; and the two concluding Waltzes--G flat major No. 1, Op. 70, and E flat major, Op. 18 “Grande valse
brilliante.” Lovers of Chopin’s music can hardly find better.

The piano sound is full and rich, the EMI engineers having
well captured the instrument’s mellow, resonant tone. It’s not too close,
either, and doesn’t stretch clear across the room as some piano recordings are
wont to do. Instead, the instrument sits comfortably before us as a real piano
might, producing warm, calming music.

JJP

Mozart and Beethoven: Ballet Music (CD review)

Roy Goodman, Vasteras
Sinfonietta. dB Productions dBCD148.

English conductor, singer, and violinist Roy Goodman has
been a professional musician for over five decades, leading any number of
well-known ensembles like the Brandenburg Consort, the Parlay of Instruments,
the Hanover Band, the English Chamber Orchestra, and the European Union Baroque
Orchestra. During this time, he’s made over 120 recordings and premiered over
40 contemporary works. But on the cover of the present album, Roy Goodman Conducts Mozart and Beethoven,
he strikes a goofy pose worthy of Latin bandleader Xavier Cugat. Paint a little
mustache on him and pretend he’s doing rumbas. Happily, there is nothing goofy
about his performances of ballet tunes from Mozart’s Idomeneo and Beethoven’s Creatures
of Prometheus.

The program begins with the little four-movement ballet
sequence that closes Mozart’s Italian-language opera Idomeneo, which he premiered in 1781. Goodman produces a lively and
buoyant opening Chaconne, followed by
a lovely, flowing Larghetto. The
conductor ensures that the transitions are seamless, so everything is of a
piece. The next two segments Goodman takes at exhilarating speeds, though never
hurried, offering up a conclusion both exciting and celebratory.

Beethoven’s dance music for The Creatures of Prometheus is much more extensive than that for
the Mozart work, of course, Beethoven’s eighteen movements comprising a full
ballet, starting with the familiar Overture.
Again, Goodman gets the show started in invigorating fashion. Most of Mozart’s
music here is pretty lightweight, to be sure, and without the actual dances as
visual markers it’s not easy to follow the story. Fortunately, in Goodman’s
hands you don’t need a story (and, yes, if you do need a narrative to follow,
you can always read along from Goodman’s booklet notes). Goodman keeps the
proceedings moving along at a healthy clip, maintaining the drama and the
fantasy of the music neatly tied together. It’s all quite delightful, really.

Goodman does suggest in his notes that the music of Creatures may have marked a turning
point in Beethoven’s output from the Classical period to Romanticism. And maybe
that’s why Goodman presents it in so fluid, imaginative, and nonrestrictive a
manner. As a final observation, if you recognize the theme in the last
movement, it’s because the composer would use it in the finale of his Third Symphony a couple of years later.
If you’re going to borrow, borrow from the best.

The engineers at dB Productions recorded the music on May
6-11, 2011, in the Vasteras Konserthus, Vasteras, Sweden. It sounds vibrant,
with excellent midrange clarity and transient response. The Vasteras
Sinfonietta is a chamber orchestra of just over thirty players, so the
recording captures a fine intimacy. Although the sound is a tad thin in the
bass and maybe a little forward at times in the lower strings, it is no cause
for alarm because there is also a touch of hall resonance as compensation. The
engineers miked the affair at a moderate distance, producing a slightly
constricted stage width but rather good depth. With dynamics that are not
particularly extraordinary but more than adequate, the result provides an enjoyably
realistic listening experience, with a sense of you-are-there presence. The
eighth-movement Allegro of The Creatures of Prometheus is
especially useful in showing off the recording’s depth and transparency.

And why the goofy cover picture? Who knows. Maybe Goodman
was up to being a little silly, or maybe he just wanted to get our attention.
He did--with his exemplary performances.

JJP

Tchaikovsky: Violin Concerto in D (SACD review)

Also, Serenade melancolique; Bruch: Scottish Fantasy. Arthur Grumiaux,
violin; Jan Krenz and Heinz Wallberg, New Philharmonia Orchestra. PentaTone
Classics SACD 5186-117.

I have always
thought of Arthur Grumiaux as a rather sedate violinist, a refined and cultured
gentleman seldom given to flights of fancy or overt showmanship. Thusly does
his 1975 recording of the Tchaikovsky Violin
Concerto strike me, a classic example of allowing the music to speak for
itself. For comparisons, I had on hand two other skilled exponents of the bow
whom I highly admire, Perlman and Heifetz, both of whom are more outwardly
showy and energetic in the work. Well, there’s no denying that Tchaikovsky
requires both technical virtuosity and a strong degree of passion, and I don’t
mean to imply that Grumiaux hasn’t qualifications in either department. There
is emotion in every note he plays. It’s just that his appears to be a more effortless
passion than the others display.

Perhaps the man
expressed his relaxed and sensitive approach to music making even better in the
disc’s companion piece, the Bruch Scottish
Fantasy, where Grumiaux allows the often-lyrical and rhapsodic folk tunes literally
to soar. It is delightful.

The sound, which
Philips recorded originally in four channels but made heretofore available only
in two-channel stereo, is, like the performances, easygoing, warm, and slightly
soft in its two-channel presentation, even in its SACD layer played back
through a Sony SACD player. I found this especially apparent in the comparisons
I made, the Perlman on a Chesky gold remastering, the Heifetz on one of  JVC’s XRCDs. Both Perlman and Heifetz
sounded noticeably more focused and precise, with better orchestral depth. I’m not suggesting, however, that
there is anything wrong with the PentaTone sound, and, indeed, many listeners
may prefer it to the more analytical presentation on the Chesky and JVC discs.

A final concern: Why
buy PentaTone? They make hybrid SACDs containing a multichannel layer (from 3
to 5.1 channels) and a regular two-channel layer. They produce some recently
recorded work and some older, quadraphonic pieces. And, as I say, they are
capable of holding up to 5.1 channels. But since Philips recorded the
Tchaikovsky and Bruch in four channels, not five-point-one, the record company
chose to keep it that way rather than try to synthesize a center channel and/or
create a separate bass. I’d say if you have the capability of playing things
back in the Super Audio CD format, PentaTone offers that distinct advantage.
Another plus is that PentaTone probably mastered even the regular stereo layer
to disc as well as it could be. I found the sound reasonably quiet, and, slightly
soft or not, still quite natural and pleasant.

Then there’s a final
reason for considering this particular PentaTone release: As far as I can tell,
no one but PentaTone is still making the performances available new (although
one can certainly find used Philips copies available). In any case, it’s a disc
worth looking into.

JJP

Famous Marches (CD review)

Eugene Ormandy,
Philadelphia Orchestra. HDTT HDCD251.

When I was growing up in the late Forties and Fifties, the
most-prominent names in the classical world were Arturo Toscanini and Leopold
Stokowski; but not far behind was Eugene Ormandy. Ormandy took over the Philadelphia Orchestra right after
Stokowski and continued in the post for well over four decades. Yet, even as a
youth I didn’t consider Ormandy a “great” conductor.” As odd as it seems, I
(and I’m sure many others) viewed Ormandy as simply a workaday conductor,
somewhat foursquare, competent but never special. It was an unfair evaluation,
to be sure; after all, Ormandy excelled in many areas, particularly in the
music of Bartok, Nielson, Orff, Rachmaninov, Shostakovich, and others. Still,
there was this image we had of a fairly ordinary conductor that millions upon
millions of people just happened to love. Oh, well....

Anyway, this album of Famous
Marches from Ormandy and the Philadelphia Orchestra tends to put the lie to
his being straightlaced; in these marches we see a meticulous conductor who
presented the music almost exactly as we always imagined it. This was no
letter-perfect Toscanini or wild-eyed Stokowski; this was a man who tried to
put as little of himself into the music as possible, letting it speak for
itself. Which is to say, these marches are not the most creative, distinctive,
or scintillating around, but they are probably pretty close to being everything
most listeners would hope they’d be.

Each of the thirteen selections on the disc is a genuine
“famous” march. You name the march, it’s probably here, starting with Sousa’s
“Star and Stripes Forever,” which you might have expected to close the show,
but it makes a nice curtain raiser. Ormandy gives it an appropriate flourish.

Among my own favorites on the program are Gounod’s
“Funeral March of the Marionette” (think Alfred
Hitchcock Presents); Verdi’s “Grand March” from Aida; Bizet’s “March of the Toreadors” from Carmen; Schubert’s regal “Marche Militaire”; and Elgar’s first and
best march, “Pomp and Circumstance No. 1,” known to high-school graduates the
world over.

Musically, Ormandy takes the “March of the Marionette” at
a slow and stately pace. Gould’s “American Salute” exhibits a great thrust and
vigor. The Aida march shows much
splendor, even if Ormandy doesn’t seem particularly imaginative about it.
Bizet’s “Toreadors” enter with a speedy rush as though already chasing bulls
around the ring; while it’s probably a tad too fast for my taste, there’s no
doubt it generates quite a lot of excitement. Victor Herbert’s “March of the
Toys” has a genuinely magical appeal to it. In Prokofiev’s satiric march from
“The Love for Three Oranges,” Ormandy provides a wonderfully faux-noble
pomposity. Johann Strauss Sr.’s “Radetzky March” displays an impressive strut.
And, finally, for sheer pomp and circumstance, you can’t beat Edward Elgar’s
“Pomp and Circumstance March No. 1,” in which Ormandy goes all out to impart as
much grand enthusiasm as possible; he may not capture all the drama of the
music as well as Sir Adrian Boult or Sir John Barbirolli did, but it’s close.

In terms of the remastered sound, it comes to us from
HDTT, High Definition Tape Transfers, the company that uses high-quality
open-reel tapes in the public domain as its source material. I found the
sonics, recorded by Columbia to a 4-track tape between 1959 and 1963,
excellent, as I have found everything from HDTT. However, it was only after
listening to the entire disc that I began thinking I’d heard it all before. I
had. I checked out my own collection afterwards and found myself amazed to find
I already had it in my collection! Well, close: What I had was a two-disc set
of the same marches and more from Ormandy and the Philadelphia Orchestra
remastered by Japanese CBS/Sony in 1983, a set I’d bought some thirty years ago
and hadn’t had the chance to listen to more than once or twice since. So not
only did I have my notes on the sound of the HDTT disc, I had another,
different remastering of the same material from Japan (presumably taken from
the master tapes) for a side-by-side comparison. I’m happy to report that the
HDTT sound was just as good as or better than the Japanese remaster.

The HDTT sound, which Columbia recorded in the Academy of
Music, Philadelphia, at various times, is at times massive and warmly
reverberant and at other times close and slightly dry. In any case, it’s always
big, big, big, as it should be in these marches, with a modest-to-strong
dynamic impact and a superwide frequency range. Highs are quite prominent,
maybe a little forward at times; midrange transparency is more than adequate;
transients sound quick and lively; stage depth is realistic; highs are
gleaming; and bass is evident when needed (that big bass drum is a band staple,
no?).

And compared to the Japanese import? The HDTT disc sounded
a touch more open and airy and perhaps just a hair brighter, with a touch of
pre-echo between tracks. The CBS/Sony discs sounded maybe a shade warmer and
smoother. It was so close, though, that one could argue a case for either
side. However, the point seems moot because the Japanese discs appear to be out
of print and unavailable even in Japan, just as the domestic Sony product has
disappeared from the catalogue. No matter; the HDTT disc holds its own quite
nicely.

As always, the folks at HDTT make their music available in
a variety of formats for a variety of pocketbooks, from Redbook CD’s, 24/96
DVD’s, and HQCD’s to 24/96 and 24/192 (on select titles) Flac downloads for
playback on high-end computer audio systems. For details, visit
http://www.highdeftapetransfers.com/storefront.php.

JJP

Hanson: Symphony No. 2 “Romantic” (CD review)

Also, Lux Aeterna;
Mosaics. Gerard Schwarz, Seattle Symphony. Naxos 8.559701.

If you’ve seen Ridley Scott’s 1979 sci-fi/horror movie Alien, you’ve heard a part of Howard
Hanson’s Second Symphony, or if you
have any Mercury LP’s or CD’s, you might have heard Hanson conducting any
number of recordings he made in the Fifties and Sixties. Hanson (1896-1981) was
a Pulitzer Prize-winning American composer, conductor, teacher, and
musicologist who gave the world quite few good musical compositions as well as
an equal number of good audiophile recordings. On the present disc, we hear his
Symphony No. 2 “Romantic” and several shorter works, Lux Aeterna and Mosaics,
all recorded by Maestro Gerard Schwarz and his Seattle Symphony in 1988, 1992,
and 1994 for the Delos label and re-released by Naxos in 2011. Schwarz’s disc
makes an excellent alternative to Hanson’s own recording of the Second Symphony for Mercury.

Hanson wrote the Symphony
No. 2 in D-flat major, Opus 30, in 1930, with the subtitle “Romantic.” The
subtitle is entirely appropriate as the work sounds much like a continuation of
late nineteenth-century Romanticism, with shades of his Romantic contemporaries
Rachmaninov and Sibelius along the way. Hanson was something of an
old-fashioned holdover in this regard, saying that his intent was to write
music “young in spirit, lyrical and romantic in temperament”; with the Symphony No. 2 he obviously succeeded.
Viewed today, it’s probably his most-famous, most-accessible work. It’s no
wonder we hear bits and pieces of it throughout popular culture.

The introductory segment of this three-movement symphony
begins with a grandly melodramatic sweep and then opens up to a beautifully
melodic theme we’ll hear in various guises throughout the work. Schwarz takes
particular delight in the more poetic aspects of the score, while giving full
measure to its rhapsodic qualities. Although Hanson tended to throw quite a lot
into the stew, Schwarz holds it all together without its becoming too
sentimental. Alien lovers will, well,
love it.

Hanson once said that he did “not believe that music is
primarily a matter of the intellect, but rather a manifestation of the
emotions.” The symphony’s Andante con
tenerezza (“moderately slow, with tenderness”) reiterates some of the first
movement’s thematic content, although in much altered form, with Schwarz taking
more of his time with it than the composer did in his own recording.

The concluding Allegro
con brio (“quick and lively, with vigor and vivacity”) starts with a
flourish worthy of Hanson’s teacher Ottorino Respighi and The Pines of Rome before settling into its lush, rhapsodic closing
material. Schwarz again emphasizes the recurring theme, this time on a more
grandiloquent scale, closing the show in fine fashion.

As companion works, Schwarz and company provide two of
Hanson’s briefer pieces, first the Lux
Aeterna (“Eternal Light”), from 1923. It was a common chant for a Requiem
Mass and probably came about as a result of Hanson’s fascination for
sixteenth-century Italian composer Giuseppe Palestrina and for Gregorian chant.
It’s a rather somber, almost melancholic work, and Schwarz probably does more
than anyone to make it seem more important and less pompous than it is. I admit
it does exude a strangely calming effect.

The second filler, Mosaic
(1957), is a later piece from Hanson, a brief set of variations in his usual
brooding Nordic style. This is maybe Hanson at his most Sibelian, so take that
as you will. Certainly, Schwarz does his best to bring out all the color and
emotional intensity in the work.

Originally, it was Delos who recorded the sound, all three
selections at the Seattle Opera House in 1988 (Symphony), 1992 (Mosaics),
and 1994 (Lux Aeterna). The sound is
quite expansive, stretching across the speakers and beyond, with a smooth
response and a reasonable degree of depth besides. The midrange sounds a trifle
thick, not as transparent in the Second
as Hanson’s Mercury recording, which remains an audiophile choice, and there is
just a hint of edge to the Seattle recording’s lower treble, evident in the
strings from time to time. A strong dynamic thrust and a touch of ambient bloom
complete a fairly lifelike acoustic picture.

JJP

Schubert: Symphonies Nos. 1 & 2 (CD review)

David Zinman,
Tonhalle Orchestra Zurich. RCA 88697 87147 2.

Maestro David Zinman and his Tonhalle Orchestra Zurich
continue their recorded cycle of Schubert symphonies with Nos. 1 and 2, which they
released concurrently with No. 7 (8)
“Unfinished.” As we would expect from this source, the performances and sound
quality are quite good, and the disc makes a welcome addition to the catalogue.

The “however” is one of personal taste: I have never
considered Schubert’s first two symphonies as anything particularly
extraordinary. The composer wrote them while in his teens, and they lack some
of the wit, charm, bounce, bubble, and inventiveness that mark his later
symphonies. The major appeals of the present recording may be for collectors
wanting some of the best available performances of Nos. 1 and 2 just for the
sake of having them, whether they like them or not, and, of course, for those
completests wishing to collect Zinman’s entire set. Still, the way Zinman plays
the two works, one has a renewed respect for them.

Austrian Franz Schubert (1897-1828) was a prolific
composer, writing nearly 1,000 pieces of music in his brief lifetime, primarily
songs, yet he failed to publish many if not most of them and failed to gain the
attention of the public at large. Given the number of truly great compositions
he left us, it seems a shame he didn’t get the credit he deserved while he
lived, but such is life. It is sometimes unfair. We live with it and,
meanwhile, enjoy the music.

Schubert wrote his Symphony
No. 1 in D major, D 82, in 1813, opening it with a grand statement in the
Beethoven vein that, nevertheless, doesn’t seem on the face of it very
remarkable. However, Zinman does bring out its life, its vitality, maybe its
impetuous youthfulness. Moreover, there is an easy flow to the music, the
rhythms dancing smoothly under the conductor’s direction. If the first movement
is Beethovenian in character, the second is most definitely Mozartian, and
Zinman approaches it with a light touch. The Minuetto and finale that follow are more dance-like than the
preceding movements, and Zinman is careful to link these qualities to the
composer’s later work.

The Symphony No. 2
in B-flat major, D 125, Schubert wrote a year later, 1814, and it is longer
and more ambitious than the First.
Again, we get a slow introduction, followed by an agitated development section
and a repeated theme. Zinman gives it plenty of spark, and the music comes
across with an exuberant joy. The Andante
finds Schubert playing with a set of variations, the theme again reminiscent of
Mozart. Then, in a sudden burst of energy, we get a scherzo-like third-movement
Minuetto and then a Presto Vivace in which Zinman with his
zesty interpretation finds and delivers great delight.

So, even though I don’t see these symphonies as anything
special from Schubert, Zinman almost makes one a believer. There may be more
here than I thought.

RCA recorded the music in February and March of 2011 in
Tonhalle Zurich, Switzerland, to generally good effect. It exhibits fine
overall imaging, depth of image, dynamics, and impact. The midrange sounds
reasonably transparent, with a more-than-adequate separation of instruments. In
all, the sonic image is open, airy, and slightly reverberant, creating a
lifelike aural experience.

Heretofore (does anybody in the real world actually say
“heretofore”? I dunno, but I like it). Heretofore, my favorite recording of
these works was by Claudio Abbado and the Chamber Orchestra of Europe (DG). And
before that in the long ago, it was an ancient LP by Sir Thomas Beecham, mono
and not very good sounding but still probably a benchmark in the works
(although I don’t have it any longer to compare). After hearing Zinman, though,
I think his reading is marginally sunnier, cheerier, and more penetrating than
Abbado’s and RCA’s sound a touch cleaner. While it’s close, I’d say Zinman is
now the man of the hour. I even like RCA’s artwork for the package.

If the RCA disc has any minor drawback, it’s the same as
Zinman’s disc of the Seventh
“Unfinished”:  It’s rather short on
content. The two symphonies take up well under an hour of playing time. As I

say, a minor concern.

JJP

Kodaly: Hary Janos Suite (HQCD review)

Also, Dances of Galanta; arias from Hary Janos. Olga Szonyi, soprano; John Leach, cymbalom; Istvan Kertesz, London Symphony Orchestra. HDTT HQCD257.



Hungarian conductor Istvan Kertesz (1929-1973) produced a remarkable string of successful recordings in his brief career, mainly during the period between 1962 and his untimely death by drowning a decade later. His performances of Bartok, Brahms, Kodaly, Mozart, Schubert, and in particular the nine Dvorak symphonies, most of which he made with the Vienna Philharmonic and as Principal Conductor of the London Symphony, remain among the best in the catalogue. Here we have an example of his work with the music of fellow Hungarian Zoltan Kodaly, a recording remastered by HDTT (High Definition Tape Transfers).



Kodaly (1882-1967) was still alive when Kertesz recorded the Hary Janos Suite and Dances of Galanta in 1964 for Decca Records, and the composer apparently enjoyed the conductor's performances of both pieces, especially the complete Hary Janos opera and the suite we have here. The folk opera Hary Janos (1926) tells of an old peasant soldier who returns to his village to spin yarns about his heroic exploits and fabulous adventures. Kodaly said he intended it to be a "mixture of realism and naivety, of comic humour and pathos." The public so enjoyed it that within the year Kodaly extracted a six-movement orchestral suite from it, which has become more popular today than the opera itself.



The six movements of the Suite bear the titles "Prelude: The Fairy Tale Begins," "Viennese Musical Clock," "Song," "The Battle and Defeat of Napoleon," "Intermezzo," and "Entrance of the Emperor and His Court." The titles are fairly self-explanatory, and Kertesz handles them with a deft touch, catching all of their whimsy and sweet sentiment. Moreover, the London Symphony Orchestra plays extraordinarily well, marking every turn of phrase with a radiant delight.



Under Kertesz, the "Prelude" begins with a sneeze (no, really) and progresses with vigor. The "Clock" displays an abundance of creative verve. The "Song," a lovely piece featuring key roles for various instruments including a cymbalom, is at first leisurely, wistful, gaining momentum in a dreamlike reverie.



"The Battle" segment was always the most demo-worthy part of the recording, largely because of Kertesz's enthusiasm for the subject matter and because of Decca's spectacular sonics. This one won't disappoint. In the "Intermezzo" that follows, Kertesz offers up a tensely effective dramatic contrast. It is also among the more easily recognizable music in the suite. Finally, Kertesz makes the "Emperor and his Court" as joyous and celebratory as any I've heard. It's a wonderfully infectious production.



The accompanying Dances of Galanta (1933) prove equally rewarding--glittering, incisive, lilting, sinewy, and resplendent by turns. Two final arias from the Hary Janos opera--"Poor am I still" and "Once I had a brood of chicks"--bring the album to a close.



This recording, which Decca made at Kingsway Hall in 1964, has always been something of a demonstration piece, and newly remastered by HDTT on an HQCD, it sounds better than ever. The stage is very wide and the sonics very dynamic. The range is enormous, with excellent air and depth to the acoustic. The midrange is impressively clear, if a tad forward and only on occasion a touch congested; the bass is more than adequate; the treble is well extended when necessary; and the separation of instruments is most lifelike. While the sound appears somewhat close up in the manner of much of Decca's work in the Sixties, it is not so close as to detract from the recording's overall realism.



As usual, the folks at HDTT make the music available in a variety of formats for a variety of pocketbooks, from Redbook CD's, 24/96 DVD's, and HQCD's to 24/96 and 24/192 (on select titles) Flac downloads for playback on high-end computer audio systems. For details, visit http://www.highdeftapetransfers.com/storefront.php.



JJP

Bruch: Scottish Fantasy (CD review)

Also, Serenade. Maxim Fedotov, violin; Dmitry Yablonsky, Russian Philharmonic Orchestra. Naxos 8.557395.



Like so many other composers, writers, and performers, Max Bruch (1838-1920) became mildly annoyed that people remembered him almost exclusively for one thing, in his case the violin concertos, and in particular the First Concerto. He did, after all, write hundreds of other works in a career that spanned over fifty years. But looked at in another light, I suppose it's better that people remember somebody well for one important thing than that they never remember the person at all.



Anyway, this Naxos disc aims to rectify the situation somewhat by presenting another famous piece by Bruch, the Scottish Fantasy from 1880, alongside a lesser-known work, the Serenade from 1900. The Fantasy is, of course, Bruch's compendium of Scottish folk tunes, over thirty minutes' worth, tied loosely together in five movements. Violinist Maxim Fedotov joins Maestro Dmitry Yablonsky and the Russian Philharmonic Orchestra in presenting both pieces.



Things begin rather oddly in the Scottish Fantasy with an introduction marked "Grave," which is exactly how violinist Maxim Fedotov plays it, literally. It's slow and solemn to the nth degree before giving way to the more familiar and frolicsome melodies that follow. However, Fedotov never really seems to let his hair down in this music, taking it all a tad more seriously than what some listeners may have in mind. Admittedly, I've become accustomed to the performances of Itzhak Perlman (EMI) and Jascha Heifetz (RCA), both of which are more joyous and outgoing than Fedotov, whose reading is somewhat more restrained and genteel.



It seems to me that Fedotov's approach to Bruch sounds better suited to the Serenade than to the Scottish Fantasy. The composer apparently first proposed the Serenade as a fourth violin concerto, which obviously never came off. Instead, we get a lyrical (yet long, almost forty minutes) set of generally Romantic themes, none of them easy to remember two minutes after hearing them. The work does not appear to have gone over too well with the public in 1900, incidentally, a public that was already finding music such as Bruch's rather old-fashioned compared to the emerging impressionism, expressionism, and such. Yet in Fedotov's hands the Serenade has a soothing lilt, even in the livelier sections. It may be entirely forgettable material, but it passes a pleasant time while it's playing.



Naxos's sound is in the big, warm category here, not revealing a lot of inner detail but most comforting to the soul after the stress of the day. For the record, so to speak, the Previn (his earlier one) is the best sounding of the three recordings of the Scottish Fantasy I had on hand, and the Heifetz is the thinnest and brightest. Still, nothing is so simple, because the Heifetz is also my favorite interpretation of the three. Oh, well....



JJP

Chopin: The Complete Preludes (CD review)

Vanessa Perez, piano. Telarc TEL-33388-02.



I was not familiar with Venezuelan-American pianist Vanessa Perez until I heard this Telarc recording of Chopin's complete Preludes. From these accounts, she certainly appears to be a pianist from whom we will be hearing much in the future.



Ms. Perez says, "The idea of recording all the Chopin Preludes came to me one night as I was playing them at home this past January. Chopin brings me back to my childhood [in Venezuela]. It connects me to every possible emotion, and to so many memories. It is music I have always loved, and that reminds me how truly blessed I am to be a pianist." Fair enough.



So, what are these Preludes of Polish pianist and composer Frederic Chopin (1810-1849), and why did he call them Preludes? "Preludes" to what? In musical terms, a prelude might be any of several things: It might be a piece that precedes a more important work or movement; it might be the overture to an opera; it might be a wholly independent piece, usually of modest length, used to introduce a fugue or a suite; or it might be any music that opens or introduces a church service. But in Chopin's case, I think his Preludes are simply short, self-contained little piano pieces that kind of resemble improvisations but are, of course, well constructed, if a little rambling. My Harvard Concise Dictionary of Music describes Chopin's Preludes as "pianistic character pieces...each usually based on a short figure or motif."



Well constructed, rambling, lacking or not lacking in formal thematic development, Chopin's twenty-four Preludes, Op. 28, which he completed in 1839, allow for a good deal of interpretation, which is why we have gotten so many different performances of them over the years from piano giants like Argerich, Arrau, Ashkenazy, Barenboim, de Larrocha, Eschenbach, Kissin, Perahia, Pollini (still my favorites), Rubinstein, and many others. From what I hear on the present disc, Ms. Perez can safely take her place among them.



Ms. Perez plays with a deft, gentle touch, capturing the subtle nuances of Chopin's music with care, feeling, respect, devotion, and love. I enjoyed the way she takes her time with the music, never hurrying it, never over dramatizing it, never over emphasizing anything unnecessarily but letting it speak for itself in smooth, delicate tones. While it may, perhaps, seem to miss some of the brawn and bravura of a few competing recordings, I've never thought of Chopin's music as anything but serene and contemplative, just as Ms. Perez presents it. It might also be easy for critics to characterize Ms. Perez's playing as somewhat sentimental, but I don't see it that way. It never sounds romanticized, just affectionately performed.



Even the quicker items, like the No. 3 Vivace in G major and the No. 11 Vivace in E major, sound poetically graceful in Ms. Perez's hands. Moreover, the most famous of the Preludes--No. 7, for instance, the little Andantino in A major, and No. 15, the popular Sostenuto in D-flat major "Raindrop"--get exquisite treatment.



Ms. Perez has the distinction, too, of making the twenty-four Preludes sound almost of a piece rather than a disparate group of separate items. Under her guidance, they ebb and flow as a unified whole, giving the illusion of a single continuous work.



Filling out the disc are four additional selections: the Prelude in C-sharp major, Op. 45; the Prelude No. 26 in A-flat major (posth.); the Barcarolle in F-sharp major, Op. 60; and the Fantasie in F minor, Op. 49. Needless to say, Ms. Perez applies the same careful, dexterous, illuminating style to them as she does to the Op. 28 Preludes.



Ms. Perez performed the works on a Hamburg Steinway CD147 piano, which Telarc recorded at Patrych Sound Studios, Bronx, New York, and released in 2012. The piano sounds beautifully balanced, not too close, not too distant, not too bright, not too soft. It projects a sweet, mellow, lightly resonant sound that nicely complements the meditative nature of the music.



JJP

Blessings, Peace & Harmony (CD review)

Gregorian Chant. Monks of the Desert, Monastery of Christ in the Desert. Sony Classical 88697 90204 2.



"...the kind of singing that we do calms the spirit and helps us live in peace with our world and with one another." --Abbot Philip Lawrence



Gregorian chant has always fascinated people, and you can find any number of recordings of it in the catalogue. Chant itself, traditionally a type of unaccompanied liturgical singing associated with the Catholic Church, has a long history, beginning with Pope Gregory in the Sixth century. It was he whom many early historians assigned credit for cataloguing and simplifying the music of the Church and after whom they named the particular kind of chant represented on this disc. Odds are, however, that Gregory had little to do with the chant we know today, which came to us mostly from centuries later. Chant does have the distinctions, though, of being among the earliest known music written out in the notation we recognize today as well as of being among the earliest examples of polyphonic music, that is, having two or more parts to produce a contrapuntal harmony.



Abbot Lawrence tells us in a booklet note that he and his Benedictine "Monks of the Desert" chose for this album to sing some of the selections because they were familiar to people, some because they were good examples of the music, and some because the monks had never done them before and just wanted to learn them. Fair enough.



About two-thirds of the music on the disc comes from the Catholic Mass. The other third come from devotional pieces, prayers for various occasions. Some of them will have titles familiar to most listeners, Catholic or not:  "Kyrie," "Gloria," "Sanctus," "Agnus Dei," "Salve festa dies," the program ending festively with five "Alleluias." The songs represent the Mass, the seasons, and, at the end of day, acknowledgement of Mary as the Mother of God.



Of course, it all comes down to the singing, and if the Monks weren't good, we wouldn't be discussing them. There are, as I say, certainly enough other recordings of chant out there to satisfy any listener. But the Monks are superb, their voices sounding as one. Although the disc booklet does not list any of their names except Abbot Lawrence (they are, after all, a modest and humble group who obviously do not wish to draw attention to themselves rather than the music), there is a picture of them, and they appear to number about fifteen. Yet the fifteen men are of a unified expression, their voices combining into a single, mellow, soothing, and wholly calming meditation. Their singing is beautiful in the extreme, their articulation, phrasing, even their breathing precise yet emotionally expressive.



The Monks of the Desert are a remarkably talented group of men who have clearly spent a good deal of time perfecting their skills. While I mentioned that their voices combine into a wonderfully integrated whole, they are distinct enough individually, too, making the overall result quite effective in more ways than one. As a group of its kind, they are as good as it gets. The monks would no doubt say they offer their songs entirely in the praise of God; we can only thank them for the comfort their voices bring us.



Sony recorded the music of the disc between 1996 and 2010 at the Monastery of Christ in the Desert, Abiquiu, New Mexico, and the Santa Fe Chamber Music Festival, Santa Fe, New Mexico. In both venues, the choir sounds pretty much the same, with the Music Festival acoustic perhaps just a tad drier. In either instance, though, the sound is full, rich, open, and reverberant, the voices well rendered in a spacious environment fully complementing the nature of the music.



As a side note, I measured my blood pressure before listening to the album and again an hour later at its conclusion.  It was 126/80 at the beginning and 120/75 at the end. You think there's something to this relaxing effect of chant?



"It is always our hope that our singing will bring others to peace, inner tranquility and an appreciation of beauty. These values can help create a world in which peace and tranquility prevail."  --Abbot Philip Lawrence



JJP

Original Masters: Leopold Stokowski (CD review)

The Decca Recordings 1965-1972. Leopold Stokowski, Czech Philharmonic Orchestra, Hilversum Radio Philharmonic Orchestra, London Symphony Orchestra, and the New Philharmonia Orchestra. Decca 475 145-2 (five-disc set).



My guess is that the average man-in-the-street wouldn't know too many of the twentieth century's great conductors besides two instantly recognizable names: Arturo Toscanini and Leopold Stokowski. It's an interesting observation because we know the two men often took almost diametrically opposed approaches to their music making, Toscanini sticking scrupulously to the letter of a composer's score and Stokowski altering the score to suit his needs. People over the years have praised and damned both men for their methods, but it is perhaps Stokowski who has incurred the wrath of more critics.



Stokowski spent the bulk of his early career in Philadelphia creating a world-class, world-famous orchestra, leaving after twenty-five years to pursue a variety of conducting jobs all over the world, working well into his mid nineties until his death in 1977. Among other things, he did a series of recordings for Decca between 1965-1972 (when he was still a mere slip of a lad in his eighties and early nineties), and the record company has collected some of them in this five-disc CD set. As usual with Stokowski, there is controversy, both with the performances and with the sound, but I can't imagine the man in any other way. Stokowski without controversy would be like salt without pepper; the two went hand-in-hand, but it took away not a whit less of his genius.



Anyhow, we find on disc one a few of Stokowski's famous, or infamous, orchestral transcriptions of piano and organ works, starting with his celebrated rendition of Bach's Toccata and Fugue for organ in D minor. I was actually in my teens before I realized Bach had originally written this work for organ. I guess I grew up on Stokowski's version for orchestra. This was one of the last times he recorded it, with the Czech Philharmonic, and it's as good as ever; as are a half dozen transcriptions of other Bach works and another half dozen of things by Byrd (Pavan and Galliard), Clarke (Trumpet voluntary), Schubert (Moment musical No. 3), Chopin (Mazurka in A minor), Tchaikovsky (Chant sans paroles), Duparc (Extase), Rachmaninov (Prelude in C sharp minor, another of Stokowski's signature pieces), and Debussy (La Cathedrale engloutie). Whether or not you agree with Stokowski's rearrangements of these pieces, there's hardly any doubt they're entertaining.



Disc two contains several of the set's most outstanding performances, Tchaikovsky's Symphony No. 5 with the New Philharmonia and Scriabin's Le Poeme de L'Extase. The Fifth Symphony takes a mite getting used to. Stokowski makes a few cuts to the work and then takes it so broadly in several sections you'd think he'd fallen asleep; yet everything seems to work out just fine, leading to some of the most rousing climaxes imaginable. The Poeme is luxurious, too, but not so vividly recorded with the Czech Philharmonic as the man's earlier Houston interpretation (Vanguard).



Disc three I didn't care for as much as the rest. It includes Frank's Symphony in D with the Hilversum Radio Philharmonic and Elgar's Enigma Variations with the Czech Philharmonic. I used to own the Elgar on LP and finally gave it away because the sound was so unrewarding. Here on CD, the sonics are better, improved mastering perhaps, but the reading still seems excessively romanticized. The old man's Franck never caught fire for me, either.



Ah, but disc four presents a different story. It starts with Berlioz's Symphonie fantastique with the New Philharmonia, a performance that does nothing particularly startling or innovative but turns out remarkably exciting. I could have wished for a less jaunty walk to the scaffold and a little more atmosphere in the "Witches Sabbath," but the work makes an excellent setting for Stokowski's showmanship and quite a demo piece. Following that are several works by Ravel, the Daphnis et Chloe Suite No. 2 with the London Symphony being another of the highlights of the box for me. It's sensuous, sensual, stirring, and as well recorded as anything in the set.



Concluding the show, disc five provides a somewhat mundane reading of Stravinsky's Firebird Suite, quite a lot of sound and fury, followed by what may be the very best thing in the box, Debussy's La Mer, in a performance of unqualified expressiveness. Bringing up the rear is Messiaen's L'Ascension, a relatively modern work (1935) of poetic mysticism that sometimes eludes Stokowski's grasp.



Decca recorded all of the music, as I've said, between 1965-1972, and they utilized their Phase-4 technology for it, an attempt to recreate a spectacular sonic reproduction with close multi-miking. Arthur Lilley was the recording engineer in these sessions, and no matter where he recorded in Phase-4, the results sounded uniformly the same. The sonics will please some listeners and infuriate others, depending on the listeners' ideas about natural sound. On the plus side, the clarity, dynamic range, and impact are often quite impressive. On the downside, bass can vary, sometimes sounding distant or weak; louder passages can occasionally break up and sound very slightly harsh; and imaging is often flat and compartmentalized. Whole sections of the orchestra may speak at once while other sections go practically dead, a hole-in-the-middle effect sometimes evoked. It can be highly enjoyable most of the time and maddening at other times.



To their credit, however, these new remasterings sound as good as or better than any of the LP's of the same material that I remember, smoother, less hard, and less glassy. The best of the lot are Daphnis et Chloe and La Mer, which appear more unified than the rest. Note, though, that none of the sound is up to the work EMI engineers were doing around the same time in the early Seventies with their competing Studio Two discs. I should also mention that as with many other Decca boxed sets, the discs are difficult to get out of their individual cardboard sleeves without leaving fingerprints. Nothing is easy.



Nevertheless, while Decca's Phase-4 sound may be a little hit-and-miss--spectacular to ordinary--it's never bad, and the performances are so compelling they surely make up for it in worthwhile listening.



JJP